Home Asia Fashion Brands Should Stop Apologising to China

Fashion Brands Should Stop Apologising to China


Luxury fashion brands Versace and Coach have apologised for making perceived affronts to China’s national sovereignty on T-shirts, mistakes that cost them their high-profile Chinese brand ambassadors.

Italy’s Dolce & Gabbana also apologised in November after its products were pulled from lucrative Chinese e-commerce platforms over an Instagram post seen by very few in China as culturally offensive. In fact the image was visually stunning and a playful take on China-Western culture.

In May 2018, US clothing retailer Gap apologised over a T-shirt showing a map of mainland China that omitted Taiwan, a self-governing island that Beijing considers a rebel province awaiting reunification.

Fashion houses are not political commentators, they are, or at least some of them are focused on an Art form, Fashion. Art should not require an apology it should be confrontational and experimental.

Some of the Chinese trolls will not be happy until everyone is producing nothing more than the once ubiquitous Chairman Mao inspired tunic.

Versace was criticised on Sunday for a T-shirt that implied Hong Kong and Macau — both semi-autonomous cities in China — were independent.

Hong Kong, operated under China’s “one country, two systems” policy, has become particularly sensitive in the mainland as the Asian financial hub has been plunged into months of pro-democracy protests.

On Monday, images of a 2018 Coach T-shirt that said Taiwan — a self-ruled democratic island — and Hong Kong were not part of China again provoked anger online.

Both companies have tried to minimise the damage.

Coach said in a statement Monday that the clothes with the “serious inaccuracy” had been pulled, adding that they were “fully aware of the severity of this error and deeply regret it”.

The brand corrected its website as well, after Chinese users shared screenshots online showing Hong Kong in a “Find By Country” drop-down list.

Versace has also apologised. “We love China and resolutely respect China’s territorial national sovereignty,” the Italian brand wrote on its Weibo account on Sunday.

The controversial T-shirts were removed from its official sales channels and “destroyed” on July 24, the company explained.

Chinese users online, however, were not mollified.

“There should be no missing part of China — Versace get out of China!” wrote one angry Weibo user Monday.

The company’s representative in China, actress Yang Mi, announced she would stop collaborating with Versace over the T-shirt incident, saying the brand was “suspected of damaging our country’s national sovereignty.”

Similarly Coach’s ambassador, Chinese model Liu Wen, announced on Monday she was terminating her work with the fashion brand over its t-shirt blunder.

“At all times, China’s national sovereignty and territorial integrity are sacred and inviolable!” she posted on her official Twitter-like Weibo account.

“I love my motherland, and resolutely defend China’s national sovereignty!” she wrote.

The two luxury brands are the latest examples of foreign companies that have run afoul of the many political sensitivities that go with operating in China’s gigantic market.

Chinese authorities and state media have lashed out particularly in recent weeks at firms that appear to back the Hong Kong demonstrations, with flagship airline Cathay Pacific facing demands that staff who supported the protests are prevented from working on flights through Chinese airspace.

Previous articleAzerai La Residence, Hue Debuts Vastly Expanded Spa and New Treatment Menu
Next articleAramco Takes a Beating
S. Jack Heffernan Ph.D. Economist at Knightsbridge holds a Ph.D. in Economics and brings with him over 25 years of trading experience in Asia and hands on experience in Venture Capital, he has been involved in several start ups that have seen market capitalization over $500m and 1 that reach a peak market cap of $15b. He has managed and overseen start ups in Crypto, Mining, Shipping, Technology and Financial Services.