Deep Insight: DJIA Vs Gold
$DIA, $GLD, $SLV
- Gold and Dow Jones’ Step Sum Symmetry
The Dow Jones Industrial Average (DIA) has broken above its BEV -5% line in the Bear’s Eye View chart below, closing the week only 4.38% from making a new BEV Zero, (new all-time high). T
Be bulls deserve a big Bravo Zulu for forcing me to change the question I ask every week. Last week I was asking whether the Dow Jones would next break above its -5% or below its -10% line. Now this week to whether it will next break below its -5% or above the -2.5% line. This is progress.
If you prefer seeing the Dow Jones in points rather than in percentage terms, here’s the Dow Jones in daily bars going back to last December and it looks really good.
Since late March the Dow Jones has reversed direction, developing a new trend with its recent pattern of higher highs and higher lows inside the trend lines I placed on the chart. The rectangle contains the market action of the past five trading weeks. I do this so you can compare this chart to the Dow Jones’ step sum table I have later in this article, which also goes back five weeks.
So what’s driving the Dow Jones higher?
Well it’s not higher earnings though I’m sure there are “market experts” who would say it is. Looking at the Dow Jones’ earnings below, they are up nicely in the past few months, but since 2012 they have been stuck in a trading range
But I have a big problem using earnings to justify movements in the broad stock market. It’s just a fact that before the Greenspan Fed (1987-2006), most market commentary said little about earnings, and for good reason. The reason for that was the stock market’s history of seeing price trends lead trends in earnings. Today this has been turned around, hence the current focus on earnings.
Look at the chart below plotting the Dow Jones (Blue Plot) to its earnings (Red Plot) from 1968 to 1984. The 1973-74 bear market occurred as earnings soared to all-time highs, and the 1982-2000 bull market began as earnings for the Dow Jones crashed.
To be sure there are periods below where the Dow Jones’ prices and earnings are in synch with each other. But following earnings during these sixteen years exposed your retirement funds to a 45% bear market decline (1973-74), and kept you out of the market at the start of a historic bull market in stocks (1982-2000).
Here’s the Dow Jones with its earnings from 1929 to 1944. In 1929, using Dow Jones earnings to decide when to buy or sell kept you in the market until they peaked in July 1930 – ouch!
Look what earnings did during the best year in Dow Jones History (July 1932 to July 1933). From the July 1932 bottom the Dow Jones soared 163% in the next twelve months as the Dow’s earning declined and then went negative. In fact, when earning once again became positive, the best year for the Dow Jones was over; and using earnings to time the market after April 1937 proved to be a losing market strategy too.
So, why are earnings so important today?
Best I can guess is during the Greenspan Fed years, the FOMC in conjunction with CNBC began focusing on earnings as a way to goose the market. CNBC went along as focusing on earnings provided a means to fill endless hours of program time in a format that advertisers (the NY big banks) found very advantageous to themselves and their clients.
But even so, this doesn’t explain how the Dow Jones’ valuation and earning trends came into synch, as seen below. That’s a question I don’t really have a good answer to. But if forced to answer that question because someone had a gun pointed at my head, I’d say (under duress) it’s because of declining standards in market regulation and accounting standards have allowed less than honest people to manipulate corporate earnings for the benefit of the elite in control of Wall Street.
But let me be very clear that without a gun pointed at my head, I wouldn’t say that, as that implies the stock market today is only a Ponzi scheme – a criminal enterprise foisted on a trusting public and their retirement funds. That would make a lot of people angry and upset. And I’m no “market expert.”
Heck I spent two decades in the Navy as an electrician, so what do I know?
Still, I have this nagging feeling had the accounting standards for corporations and the banking system of the early 1950s been rigorously maintained throughout the period seen above, the Bretton Woods’ $35 gold peg would still be in place and the plots for the Dow Jones’ valuation and earnings would look completely different than what we see above.
Watching CNBC as the high-tech bubble inflated in the late 1990s was hilarious. Quarterly they’d have what was then called “Earnings Central”; Earnings Theater would have been more accurate.
Days before a bellwether dot.com or semiconductor stock was to report its earnings, CNBC would start a countdown on their screen as “market experts” discussed the pros and cons of this, that and the other thing that could impact a company’s earnings. On the day the company was to report its earnings, always around 2PM, the drama reached fever pitch.
On the announcement, more times than not the actual reported earnings would exceed the analysis’ guesses by a penny, it always seemed like a penny. After which that particular glamor stock’s share price would surge upward, sometimes by double-digits percentages taking the NASDAQ and Dow Jones up with it. This farce continued for years.
But all that was back when being a “Master-of-the-Universe” meant something. Today, yesterday’s “Masters-of-the-Universe” are buying bunkers to protect themselves from Doomsday.
Nuff said about all that; time to move on to gold’s BEV chart below. Gold broke below its BEV -35% line on July 19th and has been holding its own since then.
What should investors do?
First understand why it is you’re buying gold. If you agree with my views on the financial markets under current management, then even gold purchased in September 2011 at over $1880 an ounce is still a hold. If today you can purchase more gold at a 35% discount from seven years ago that is only a good thing.
However, like my readers I too am frustrated by the current decline in the price of gold. I just keep in mind that no market trend lasts forever, so this too shall pass. And besides believing that, knowing how the “policy makers” are rigging the price of gold and silver down in the COMEX futures market, by selling tons of digital-gold that doesn’t exist, I’m smiling inside thinking is this all they can do, and what happens when this trend reverses, as one day it must.
Looking at gold’s step sum chart, not much has changed from last week. One thing that may be notable, the current decline in gold began in March. After four months this decline is getting stale. We could see a bounce upward come this August or September.
The Dow Jones and its step sum are looking good. Daily advances dominate the declines; the rising step sum plot tells us that. That plus the Dow Jones is rising in response. Not much more to say about that, except wonder should the Dow Jones make a new all-time high – what happens then? We need to keep in mind that the current advance began in March 2009, an advance that took the Dow Jones up by over 21,000 points. How much more can the stock market offer investors?
Here are gold and the Dow Jones’ step sum tables.
The thing to note is their daily 15 counts. In the past five trading weeks (25 trading days) gold has seen only negative counts, with lots of -5s & -7s to be seen below. That’s serious downward pressure on the price of gold, and for all that gold is down only 3.62% from June 22nd?
The Dow Jones’ table is a mirror image of gold’s. Since July 9th its 15 counts have been positive, with lots of +7s and three +9 to be seen. This is a market with its afterburners lit; still the Dow Jones has advanced by only 3.54% since June 22nd. Excuse me for thinking so many advancing days should have delivered more.
Exactly how long these markets can maintain these trends is the question. It’s hard for the bears to keep slamming a market with as many declining days we see in the gold market, and for the bulls drive prices higher day after day with the frequency we see on the Dow Jones side. However, these trends may go on longer than you or I believe they can, but the day is coming when they will reverse.
It will be interesting to see what gold does when its step sum chart looks like the Dow’s side does, and what the Dow does when its step sum chart appears as gold’s does now.
I do a lot of work with daily steps, the daily ups and downs of the market. I was inspired by something Richard Russell used to say about the Dow Theory, “letting the Dow Jones tell its own story.” I never worked in the financial industry; rather I began following the markets as a hobby while I was in the Navy. Like most people seriously following the markets, I read books on technical analysis to better understand the data I was compiling. However the thought occurred to me that most of these techniques were widely followed, and frequently used in the financial media for public consumption. Doing what everyone else was wasn’t attractive to me.
So, I decided to see what market insights could be discovered using the daily ups and downs in the Dow Jones as a single item Advance – Decline Line: my step sum. As the Great Depression crash is still the most widely remembered market event in all history, even after many decades have passed, I decided to construct a step sum plot of the last few years of the Roaring 1920s Bull Market and the market crash that followed. What I saw plotted below was, and still is a stunning chart.
It’s predictable during the bull market of the 1920s the Dow Jones (Blue Plot) would have seen more daily advances than declines (Red Plot / Step Sum) or that during the initial deflationary collapse of September – November 1929 the Dow Jones would have seen more daily declines than advances.
But weeks after the November 1929 to April 1930 dead-cat bounce, who’d believed as the Dow Jones began its 89% collapse of July 1932 it would do so with more daily advances than declines for almost a full year, as seen inside the Bear Box? Then as the Dow Jones approached its ultimate bear market bottom, daily advances in the Dow Jones were overwhelmed by declining days, resulting in the collapse in the Step Sum.
Without a doubt, something important was going on here, but what? If you look at the plots above as the valuation of the Dow Jones (Blue) being market reality, and the A-D Line (Red Step Sum) computed using the daily advances and declines of the Dow Jones as market sentiment, it makes a lot of sense.
When did the Dow’s step sum become decoupled from the valuation of the Dow Jones itself? Not at the September 1929 market top, but as the dead cat bounce began collapsing in April 1930 because the Bulls believed the -47.87% decline of November 13th1929 was the bottom. People were committing suicide at the November 1929 bottom. The bulls must have reasoned how much worse could it get? We can see when the bulls finally admitted they were wrong, February 1931 when the bear box closed with the collapse in the step sum as it recoupled with the Dow Jones’ price trend.
Seeing the trend of a step sum decouple from its price trend can be seen below in the gold market. It happened three times since 1969:
- 1988 to 1996 (8 year bear box)
- 1999 to 2001 (3 year Bull box)
- 2011 to 2015 (4 year bear box)
We also see a bull box below, where from 1999 to 2001 gold’s step sum collapsed (declining days overwhelm advances) with little effect on the price of gold.
I have covered these charts in the past, but a little review is always good.
However the real purpose I’m publishing these charts this week is for background for the following chart plotting the daily step-sum symmetry between the Dow Jones and gold. Symmetry, what is that? The fact is for most days when the Dow Jones advances, so does the price of gold. And for most days when the price of gold goes down, so does the Dow Jones. That sounds symmetrical to me.
To construct the daily-data points to be plotted, I used the following logic table for the symmetry found in the Dow Jones and Gold Markets. On those days when the symmetry between the daily advances and declines in the gold and Dow Jones holds, each going up or down with each other, my logic table produces a Zero.
When the symmetry is broken by gold advancing as the Dow Jones declines, my logic table produces a +1, and when the Dow Jones advance as gold declines produces a -1.
Obviously later in this article I’m going to use this data in a chart, and it’s key to understand how this logic is biased for gold. More daily advances for gold than the Dow Jones drives the plot up. More daily advances for the Dow Jones than gold drives the plot down.
The above frequency table displays how many days the symmetry between the gold and the Dow Jones held, producing a Zero: 5801 days since 02 June 1969 (46.6% of daily closings). Those days where the symmetry was broken in gold’s favor numbered 3263, and 3385 days closed with the symmetry broken in favor of the Dow Jones. I took the net of the +1 and -1, which tells us that since June 1969 there were 122 net days where the Dow Jones closed higher as the price of gold declined (-1).
Below is a table listing the symmetry data for gold and the Dow Jones for the past 100 days. As expected, days where gold and the Dow Jones closed up or down together (0), dominate those where the two went their own ways resulting in a +1 or -1 for the day.
Next is the frequency distribution for the 100 days above placed over the frequency distribution since June 1969. Comparing the data in the Percent of Total Days columns of these two tables it’s apparent the gold market has seen considerable selling pressure since early March.
Looking at the Net 1 & -1 data above, of the 122 net this data has since 1969, a full 10 of these -1 (Gold Down / Dow Jones UP daily closings) have occurred since March 7th. Seeing 8% of the nets of the past five decades occur in the past one hundred days suggests something or someone is applying a lot of pressure on the price of gold.
All the above was background for the following chart plotting the symmetry for the price of gold and the Dow Jones. Text boxes are provided to fix the bull and bear markets gold has seen since 1969. As expected, during gold-bull markets the plot advances as the price of gold sees more daily advances than does the Dow Jones, as during gold-bear markets the plot declines as the Dow Jones sees more daily advances than does gold.
But this is not always the case.
From January 1980 to December 1984 (black circle) the price of gold declined 60% with the Dow Jones advancing 36% as the plot trended sideways for these five years. Then when gold’s 1980-99 bear market hit its absolute bottom of $253.7 on 19 July 1999, we see the symmetry plot continue declining for the next three years until gold made a double bottom with a $255.1 close in February 2001 (Green Triangle). A few months later the gold bull market began in earnest when for the first time since 1979, gold began seeing more net daily advances than did the Dow Jones, pushing the plot upwards.
The latest advance in gold terminated in September 2011, fourteen months later we see the Gold / Dow Jones Symmetry plot begin its current decline. Something interesting to note about the current decline; in the past year (July 2017 to July 2018) the symmetry plot has collapsed by 29 – that’s a big drop for a single year.
So what should we make of all this?
I don’t believe this data is practical for use in forming short-term opinions on the market, however it provides a superb view of the gold and stock markets’ rear-view mirror.
The 1969-80 bull market in gold makes perfect sense. In a decade where CPI inflation was in the high single and double digits, and the stock market found itself in a malaise, as President Jimmy Carter noted, that gold would see more daily advances than would the Dow Jones.
The 1980-99 gold bear market also makes sense. For the best part of two decades monetary inflation ceased flowing into CPI inflation (consumer prices) and flowed into financial asset valuations. Why would people want to buy gold when the big bucks were being made in the stock and bond markets? So, considering where the FOMC’s monetary inflation was flowing into, it’s expected the daily advances in the Dow Jones would dominate over gold causing the symmetry plot to decline by over 200 net Dow Jones advances.
The 1999-2011 advance in gold began slow. It began in a time when investors were focused on their high-tech future in the NASDAQ. But six months after gold’s July 1999’s $253 bottom, everyone’s high-tech future began deflating.
By the summer of 2001, as the NASDAQ high-tech bubble continued deflating, it was obvious to the smart-money crowd that the “policy makers” were reflating the financial markets by “injecting liquidity” into the retail-mortgage market. The wisdom of encouraging consumers to assume hundreds-of-thousands of dollars of debt for housing to inflate another asset bubble seemed dubious to reasonable people. By October 2008 everyone else, including the US Congress came to the same opinion. Considering everything, is it really surprising that from 2001 to 2011 gold saw more daily advances than did the Dow Jones?
Here is another point that I believe is important.
Before 2001 most new stories about central banks and their gold reserves were ones of them selling their gold, after 2001 these stories switched to central banks buying gold.
So what changed after September 2011 that would result in the above plot to decline?
Really nothing, actually the reasons for gold, silver and the precious metals mining shares to rise have only gotten better as their prices have declined for these past seven years.
- The global banking system is still on life support.
- Debt loading on the global economy has become even more onerous.
- Financial assets and real estate valuations have become even more inflated than they were in 2007.
These are just 3 factors for liking gold, but there are many more.
One point Richard Russell always stressed was how market trends would continue until they reach their point of EXHAUSTION, the point where they simply can’t continue on.
Points of exhaustion pertain to bull markets, and we’re seeing stories that strongly suggest we’re rapidly approaching one in the current bull market on Wall Street. In my opinion, seeing a glamour stock like Facebook drop 19% in a single trading session is a shot fired across the bow from Mr Bear warning of worse things to come.
And then on Friday July 27th shares of Twitter dropped by 20.5%.
Seeing glamour stocks’ valuation drop by double digit percentages in a single trading session is something that happens at market tops.
Problems can be seen outside the stock market too.
California real estate is seeing early signs of trouble in the link below. Home prices are at record highs (not a good sign), and alarmingly the volume of home sales themselves have been reduced by 11% from a year ago. Apparently rising mortgage rates are shrinking the pool of perspective qualified buyers.
Bear markets also reach their points of exhaustion.
Looking back at history, the points of exhaustion for the Great Depression Crash and for the market declines in the price of gold since 1969 can easily be identified in their step sum charts posted earlier in this article.
Here’s something to understand and hold on to in our current market: valuations for gold, silver and their miners ARE NOT driven higher by monetary inflation. Monetary inflation comes from the banking system, and the banking system “injects” their “liquidity” into stocks, bonds and real estate. So it’s actually valuations in financial assets that are driven higher by monetary inflation; not precious metal assets.
What fuels bull markets in gold, silver and their miners is DEFLATION in stocks, bonds and real estate. During bear markets in financial assets, capital fleeing deflation flows naturally towards assets with zero counter-party risks, such as gold and silver, which greatly benefits their miners. So I’m not going to get too excited about the old monetary metals until we see the stock, bond and real estate markets gets a dose of deflation from Mr Bear.
Seeing into the future is not so simple, but given pending, yet unknown developments we can anticipate.
Go back and review my chart on the step-sum symmetry for gold and the Dow Jones above and take a good look at the box covering the last year of the plot. Seeing this plot drop by 29 in a single year is a BIG drop, and I have to wonder whether we are reaching a point of exhaustion for both the bull market on Wall Street and the current market decline in the price of gold.
By Mark Lundeen
Paul Ebeling, Editor
Have a terrific week
Latest posts by Paul Ebeling (see all)
- The Street’s Key Stock Analysts Research Reports - June 26, 2019
- Asia: Gold, USD, Crude Oil, Stocks & Commodities - June 26, 2019
- President Trump,”I Do Not Need Exit Strategies if War With Iran” - June 25, 2019