Arcane Financial Products That Track VIX Questioned
$CBOE, $VXX, $CS, $NMR
Wall Street’s most widely followed ‘fear gauge’ of future stock market volatility is being manipulated, causing billions of dollars in losses a year to unwary investors, a law firm representing an “anonymous whistleblower” alleged in a letter to US financial regulators and released Monday.
The letter, to both the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), was proffered by a Washington-based law firm which represents the anonymous person claiming to have held senior roles in the investment business.
Claims in the letter outline how trading firms have taken advantage of the way the Cboe Volatility Index (VIX) is being calculated in order to manipulate the index.
Arcane financial products that track the VIX are at the center of the current stock market ructions that have seen US benchmark equities fall in and out of 10% correction territory since late January after a record long run of very low volatility.
“The flaw allows trading firms with advanced algorithms to move the VIX up or down by simply posting quotes on S&P options and without needing to physically engage in any trading or deploying any capital,” Jason Zuckerman of Zuckerman Law said in the letter.
Cboe Global Markets (NASDAQ:CBOE), home to the VIX, pushed back against the allegations.
The VIX estimates the expected near-term volatility conveyed by S&P 500 index option prices. The index relies on mid-quote prices of select out-of-the-money SPX call and put contracts, among other things.
At the time of settlement of VIX futures, the CBOE calculates an official settlement level of the VIX based on a special monthly settlement auction of S&P 500 options.
This settlement price ultimately determines whether large blocks of VIX futures expire worthless or turn a profit.
Attorney Zuckerman alleges that trading firms have manipulated the VIX index to their advantage by posting quotes for S&P 500 options, without any actual corresponding trades.
But William Speth, vice president, head of Research at Cboe, said: “There are structural safeguards built into the process of the calculation of the VIX settlement value that would hinder the type of manipulation the letter alleges.”
He added that “our regulatory group actively surveils for potential VIX settlement manipulation.”
The letter alleges that manipulation of the volatility index also played a role in recent wild price moves of certain volatility-linked ETFs (exchange traded products).
Last week, Credit Suisse Group AG (NYSE:CS) and Nomura Co Ltd (NYSE:NMR), last week, said they would terminate two ETPs that bet on low volatility in stock prices.
Those announcements followed dives in the ETP prices as the price of VIX futures soared following a sharp drop in US stocks on Monday, 5 February.
The SEC declined to comment. The CFTC was not immediately reachable for comment.
Latest posts by Paul Ebeling (see all)
- The Street’s Key Stock Analysts Research Reports - September 24, 2018
- Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA) Need Lots More Cash, What is Going to Happen? - September 24, 2018
- Commentary: Paul Ebeling on Wall Street - September 24, 2018